Help me choose a new breeding male?

Hi! I have two males that I've been tossing up over for a wee while and decided it might be best to as all you which you like better and would be more likely to breed with?

Here are the two:

Kilída He has 239 stats currently, Charming personality, and more exclusive marks

Selkie 321 stats at the moment, Imaginative personality - less exclusive marks but also so pretty :0 - will likely change his base to a tier II when events come

So what do you guys think?? 

Just a personal opinion, but I'd go for the second one.

I'd do the second one, but definitely agree to base change to something Tier II, since you can't see the base anyway under all the marks :)  Better chance of more Tier II base babies, which will sell better, and higher stats at starting will also benefit if you are going to level him up and make him a breeding male or a scout.