Allow All Males to Breed within the Pack

The limiting factor of pups saturating the market is that more males in a pack = less females in heat = less litters. No breeding limit needed. 

And pups are already saturating the market anyway. So many people breed a female every heat regardless, there are still tons of unwanted puppies. (myself included, though I've been chasing useless pups instead of trying to sell them.)
Allowing other males to breed just means the deluge of unwanted puppies will have more diversity. Those users that aren't breeding their females every heat will likely continue to do so, those that already were won't change.

It might actually mean fewer overall puppies born since people might be more inclined to keep males instead of having dens full of females.

On an aside, I like the new "in current pack for ____ rollovers" feature.
One concern with this suggestion has been, depending on how it's implemented, is people sending females to other people for that "in-pack" breeding with a non-breeding male, not only bypassing the intended stud feature but also being easy to abuse and a nightmare to moderate. If one of the requirements is both wolves have been in the same pack long enough to make these sorts of breedings take a prohibitively long time for most users that would be a good deterrent.

Supporting this, for both gameplay and realism purposes.

Thought maybe I'd get used to this over time and no longer feel like 1-male-only is a bad idea, but nope, here we are. How on earth are you supposed to do any sort of marking-based breeding project when you only reasonably have control over one half of the process? Unless you want to keep changing your stud, or you're just trying to inbreed back to him to get pups closer to him in appearance (?? in which case it's not even really a breeding project?) This game would be absolute top tier if I could actually breed for specific visual goals without it feeling like there's a completely arbitrary handicap. As of right now all I really care to do is aim for stats and customize my pups to be nice looking, and I don't know for how long that can stay entertaining, honestly.

It's not like I wouldn't be using an equivalent amount of GC items to finish up project wolves (who's gonna put all that effort into breeding for specifically, idk, slot 6 black butcher? :p)

I support this! A lot of the problems said I feel have been addressed; and like @Owlbear said, to limit bypassing the stud system, make it so non-stud males can't breed with a female in the pack if they've been there for less than a certain amount of rollovers. 

In fact, you could go as far as to lock down a solid number to 4 rollovers as heats will only last for that long, on top of a breeding cooldown. I could see where the issue of planning ahead for studdings can come in, so make it against the rules to advertise non-stud males as studdable (Devs have shown that they're willing to intervene like this with the Mutation Carrier vs. Potential Mutation Carrier update). 

love this idea! to balance the non-stud males i suggest the following (a lot of this has probably already been said):

1) very limited slots for non-studs. 1-3 seems fair to me
2) a stat requirement to become a non-stud breeding male? or a level requirement?
3) maybe personality compatibility could come into play?
4) ofc, no mating with outside females for non-studs

basically, make it so there is a reason to keep males. it could be super fun for lore and provide incentive to trade males around so people can find the perfect mate for their wolves!

I find issue with the 1-3 limit since this was brought up by a few already. This would be fine IF the limit is per account and would reset for when they're sold other wise they'd become worthless again after up to 3 uses and people will just get rid of them as before. 

though the limit reset when a wolf is traded or sold may be hard to code so. a better way may be an option. We of course don't want any abuse of this feature and bypassing what shouldn't be. 

Maybe, Have the males in your pack only work for your account and i like the idea someone brought up on the 'they cannot breed if they recently joined after so much days' it of course has to be long enough to ignore any females in heat this round. 

and i love a fair breed cooldown. I'd be fine with it matching a female's despite them not really needing it so he can't breed quickly after. Of course, even with a slightly shorter cooldown, it'd be fine i guess...maybe we need a test run to see how it works like the staff could have it tested and adjust as needed? 

I would very much like more incentive to keep and get attached to males. Also has there been any thoughts from mods on this?

Supporting this, I would enjoy being able to breed other males I have.

Honestly in the beginning I wasn't sure how I felt about this suggestion, but the more I think about it the more I support. I would also want to have my heir be a direct descendant of my two lead wolves (lead and breeder male) but I would like to have a couple litters born to her first from her future mate (future breeder male) without my current leads being dead. I think a breeding cooldown for males would make a lot of sense! Make it the same as a female's cooldown and it will help curb the rising amount of unwanted pups in game. Whenever I have male pups born they either take forever to sell, or don't sell at all and wind up chased.

In short, I support!